You know how some moments of your life seem to stick with you? It's as though your brain randomly selects those moments and locks them into a permanent holding tank that doesn't fade even as other memories slip away.
I have one such memory of a conversation that has since become meaningful to me as I consider Orthodoxy.
A church I once attended was going through a transitional period, to say the least. There had been some rough patches, but the leaders and the congregation truly wanted to serve God and the people around them.
I remember being part of a group of people who were discussing possible changes. How should we orient the seating? Where should the "stage" be? What about having couches in the back, or lounge style tables with tall chairs, like in a coffee shop? What about the art on the walls - perhaps something artistic that depicts God's love in a creative way?
One of the leaders - a young, cool guy who we all generally liked and respected - said this (and yes, I oddly remember his quote verbatim):
"We're starting fresh here. We can do whatever we want."
The implication of course was meant to be a positive one. We can really go the extra mile to make our service more "user-friendly." More "seeker-centered." More "relevant." Those are all good things, right?
But there's a dark and shifty danger in the idea that "We can do whatever we want." It is born when we start to imagine that we could (or should) use our own measuring stick to assess the worship of God. It grows out of infancy when we begin to apply our own wisdom and skills to define what worship truly should look like. And it becomes a tyrannical monster when we feel we've achieved (by our own decisions, our own choices, our own talent) the pinnacle of what church was really meant to be.
Of course, people largely have the best of intentions. At least, that's what I believe. But that's what's so sneaky about evil. It doesn't come charging in with a battering ram to announce itself. It slips quietly through the back door, perches imperceptibly on the shoulder, and whispers half-truths that have the sound of genius about them. If we let it in, it clouds the mind and sedates the heart, lulling us into submission when we didn't even realize there was an enemy about.
Today at Redeemer Pesbyterian, Rev. Cassidy spoke about "me-centered worship" vs. "God-centered worship." I appreciated the truth he shared and feel he is probably right on. What I wonder about is this: Are we even able to see just how rooted we've become in the "me-centered" worldview?
We're a culture of rebels. (Hey, that's not entirely bad!)
In a recent book (you'll have to forgive me - I believe it was Orthodoxy and Heterodoxy but I'm fuzzy on the details and can't go check for a reference at the moment) - the author of said book pointed out that in America, we have been brought up in a worldview that champions revolution. Our great nation was born out of revolution (something we see as a positive) - our brave forefathers kicked off the constraints of England and worked to create their own, better state (again, a positive). The Reformation was seen similarly, and the Reformers became saintly figures (without the title, of course - because that would be too Catholic). :)
While other cultures might inherently have a deep respect for time-honored tradition, our culture was created by men and women who were willing to
question the old ways. We are always striving for change - for the next best thing.
So, naturally, being an American leads me to have a natural propensity to value the new and to be cautious of the old.
It was amazing the first time I was able to step outside of myself for just a moment and to look at myself, at my neighbors, at our culture. We really do seem to be a culture of "reformers" and "revolutionists!"
Why am I bringing this up?
I think it's helpful to recognize that much of what we may deem to be "common sense" may actually be "cultural sense." We perceive only what we are able to perceive through the filmy lens of our cultural perspective.
So when a small internal voice says, "We can do whatever we want," it sounds a lot like wisdom to our culturally-trained ears.
"Whittled to fit the same shape..."
I want to close with another excerpt from
The Illumined Heart. This little 100 page volume gives us a lot of good things to think about. :)
In a chapter titled "Why we don't like repentance," Frederica Mathewes-Green talks about the me-centered, consumer-based culture that we live in. Whether we like it or not, it colors how we see ourselves, God, and the world around us. We believe (because everbody seems to believe) that our personal happiness and wellbeing is central to our life's purpose. We are at the center.
Unfortunately, we can easily apply this same worldview when seeking God. And the scary thing is that we have no idea that we're doing it.
Please note that the emphasis added below is all mine.
......
Excerpt from The Illumined Heart by Frederica Mathewes-Green, pg. 33-35
I call this the Frosting Cycle. Imagine the person who decides to comfort herself with a can of chocolate frosting. For a whie it tastes very, very good, and she feels better - and then she starts feeling a good bit worse. Submerged in bad, icky feelings, what can she do? Then the can's bright label catches her eye, and she thinks, "Chocolate makes me feel better."
This cycle of excessive consuming just adds to our lousy feelings. It is debilitating to see ourselves as passive, nonproductive gluttons. But even to the sickness of too-much we can't see any solution except buying, acquiring, seducing, viewing, eating, or drinking more. Self-esteem is wrecked by self-indulgence, because a million self-indulgences add up to a person you can't respect very much.
Thus, when we face eternal questions like "Why is the world so messed up?" and "How am I part of the problem?" we have a reduced pack of available answers. The quick answer, "Buy something and forget about it," is supremely seductive. It's also a more available solution than it was for our forebears.
Many well-intentioned sources try to help by addressing the symptom rather than the disease, offering advice on gaining self-esteem or losing guilt or becoming more assertive in our quest for extra frosting. A good bit of the self-help section of any bookstore will be filled with titles about consoling and pampering ourselves, self-pity titles, and advice on getting others to give us what we want.
Unfortunately, if we move over to the Christian bookstore, we will find much the same tone. Here, I'm sorry to say, Jesus is too often offered as a consoler whose only purpose is to meet our needs. His focus is on us, and we are invited to take the role of unhappy child and bask in that doting care.
I can understand where this approach comes from. It's true that Jesus is the only answer to this eternal problem, the problem of meaninglessness and loneliness. When the surrounding culture thinks in terms of "What can meet my need?" or "Where can I get the frosting I deserve?" it's natural for Christians to say, "What you're really looking for is Jesus. He does what frosting does, and more."
But the basic attitude of "How can I get what I want?" has still not been questioned. It hasn't even been recognized. "Jesus" may be a different answer from the one given by advertising, entertainment, and the consumer culture, but it's been whittled to fit the same shape.
.....
Though we have the best of intentions, modern Christians are at risk of using Jesus as the answer to the self-serving question of "How can I get what I want?" instead of putting ourselves aside and asking "What does God want of me?"
But there is hope...
While church in American continues to be shaped in quiet ways by the surrounding culture, there is a church that has
transcended culture for several thousand years.
It can show us, if we dare to look, what worshiping God looked like in the original church, before it was tainted by our judgments and corrections.
When we "try on" this new church perspective, some of it will itch and scrape. But we shouldn't be persuaded by the voice on our shoulder that those feelings of discomfort betray a falsehood. In actuality, it's just the discomfort we find in trading one worldview for a completely different one.
After all, we must recognize that any "me-centered" message ("I should prioritize my own comfort") is more likely a dangerous enemy than a trusted friend.
Glory to Thee Oh Our God, A Glory To Thee!